Score: 10

"nice"

submission: Guitar Challenge-SorohanroSolo

date: January 3, 2009

Well this is a very charming track. Although the guitar is a bit sloppy at times it makes up for it in other arias.

Score: 8

"deconstructed it's pretty good."

submission: Me and my Garage

date: December 16, 2008

There are a lot of parts of this song that sound really good on there own but while combined they seem to clash a little bit. I really liked the beat, the melodies were cool great too, but some of them didn't fit the beat rhythmically and others kind of sounded out of place in the song, but than when you peeled a part of the song away and I heard a melody on it's own it sounded fine.

Score: 7

"wellllllllll"

submission: b0mBz - Creation

date: December 7, 2008

kind of dull at first. liked the appragio part that comes in, not sure about the rest of the song though. What kind of scale are you using? Chord progressions? Music thoery?
Eh, usic thoery has no laws, no rules... only a few loose guidelines. It's really relative and it seems a lot of people like what they've heard here.

Score: 10

"nice"

submission: Caves

date: December 4, 2008

Has a very Blizzard feel to it. Like the first Diablo, plus that bass reminds me of some of the Terran songs from Starcraft. It kind of has the best from both worlds and a little bit more, I like it.

Score: 8

"hmmm genre?"

submission: Space Lullaby

date: November 19, 2008

not terribly exciting but I guess that's not what you're going for. It's an interesting melody. I'd reclassify it as ambient, it really isn't what most people would think of as trance but there is enough background noise for it to fit into ambient probably.

Score: 10

"Nice"

submission: Mario World castle HEAVY !!

date: November 18, 2008

It's pretty good, every now and again a chord sounds a little off, like it doesn't follow the chord progression or something. But it's not too noticeable, certainly not enough to ruin this great piece.

Score: 4

"well..."

submission: {IDR}-Against The Blue

date: November 6, 2008

I suppose my problem with it is that it never really picks up, when it does it simply isn't enough given how long it takes to build up. The song seems like it's going to break out in many places but it always fails to satisfy.

There is nothing horribly wrong with the song, it just isn't all that exciting.

Score: 10

"Diggin the eight bit in this"

submission: 8b01 icarus

date: November 6, 2008

The song would have been pretty good with other synthesizers, probably would have been nice with guitar or anything else. It's a good melody, but the eight bit just makes it perfect. I gave it a five.

Score: 9

"alright..."

submission: A-Team - The Computer Game

date: November 4, 2008

haha, great song the A-Team. but the synth was too, I don't know heavy or distorted something.

Score: 8

"huh, interesting"

submission: MC Kids Trash Rock

date: November 4, 2008

It has it's good parts and it's bad parts. It veries by the voices you used, I can see how people might not like how the rhythm gives a little skip every now and agian but I think it's kind of interesting. So like I said before, good parts and bad parts, but in my opinion it's mostly good.